dashblog logo
Sign up with your email address to be the first to know about new products, VIP offers, blog features & more.
[mc4wp_form id="4288"]

4-Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies

4-Ingredient, Healthy-Girl Peanut Butter Cookies // Hustle + Halcyon

Heyya Girly Galz.

Important Updates: I’ve been working on a really sweet little project with Planet Blue for the opening of the Planet Blue Houston store, & y’all are going to DIE. Planet Blue threads + Claire Huntsberger photography + Texas vibes = the best thing since, well, anything ever. Sooon, my people.

Also, I’m going CRAZY eating at restaurants here in Los Angeles for DINE LA ( a two-week event in which local restaurants offer full, 3-4 course meals for a set ( cheap AF ) price ). Considering I’m moving in less than a month, I figured I should take full advantage of the LA foodie scene, coupled with affordable prices… because nothing is ever affordable here. I just have to try out more restaurants for my GUIDE TO LOS ANGELESright?? It’s “research.” Follow along the foodie adventures on Snapchat (payton_sartain) & Instagram.

Okay, so: these 4-Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies.

I’ve been a fan of the recipe for awhile now ( I found it at the beginning of College ), and it’s my usual ‘I’m hungry at 2 AM & there’s nothing sweet to eat’ recipe. It’s super quick & simple ( if y’all have been reading H+H for a bit now, you know this is kind of my ‘thing’ ), not HORRIBLE for you, and actually so incredibly delish. Here’s the dealio…

4-Ingredient, Healthy-Girl Peanut Butter Cookies // Hustle + Halcyon


♥ 1 Cup Peanut Butter
♥ 1 Cup Sugar
♥ 1 Tsp Baking Soda
♥ 1 Egg


♥ Preheat oven to 350°
♥ Mix together PB & Sugar, and then stir in the Baking Soda & Egg.
♥ Scoop cookies onto lined baking sheet, about 1 Tablespoon ( or more ) per cookie.
♥ Optional: with a fork, create the lattice-effect ( idk why, but I’m weird and I think they taste & look better when you do this… *not scientifically proven, but whatever* )
♥ Bake for about 10 minutes, or a couple minutes more if you like your cookies more crispy.
♥ Eat them all in one sitting.

Eeeeep, I’m getting a sweet tooth just thinking about them.

Like I said, these aren’t HORRIBLE for you, but I wouldn’t say they’re exactly nutritious either. I recommend this recipe for a little sugar fix…. aka don’t be me & actually eat them all in one sitting. I need to stop doing that.

They’re super addicting, so beware.

You’ve been warned.


PS: For more recipes like this, visit my Recipe Index!


5 Responses
  • Marina
    07 . 14 . 2015

    I 100% need to try these once I’m back in my apartment with a fully functioning kitchen, haha!

    • payton@hustleandhalcyon.com
      07 . 14 . 2015

      They are to-die-for. For Real.

  • jenna
    07 . 14 . 2015

    Need to try these babies.

  • Ellen Smith
    07 . 14 . 2015

    I absolutely love peanut butter so I am gonna have to give this a try, it looks so delicious.
    I love your recipes Payton.


  • kenzie negron
    07 . 15 . 2015

    omg, these look delicious! x kenz